5 Reasons Why Environmentalists and Animal Activists Should Occupy Wall Street

by Will Potter on October 13, 2011

in Activism & Activists' Response

City by city, it’s growing. If you have been watching the rise of Occupy Wall Street from the sidelines, maybe it’s because you’re not sure if you’re part of the “99 percent” or maybe it’s because you just have other things to do. Here’s the thing: This is bigger than one person, one issue, or one movement.

Here are five reasons why environmental activists and animal rights activists should Occupy Wall Street:

1) Corporations are destroying the planet. And, as Bill McKibben wrote, “For too long, Wall Street has been occupying the offices of our government, and the cloakrooms of our legislatures.” The first official Declaration of the Occupation of New York City articulated some of the many facets of this movement, including environmental and animal rights concerns. Here are a few highlights:

“As we gather together in solidarity to express a feeling of mass injustice, we must not lose sight of what brought us together. We write so that all people who feel wronged by the corporate forces of the world can know that we are your allies..

They have poisoned the food supply through negligence, and undermined the farming system through monopolization.

They have profited off of the torture, confinement, and cruel treatment of countless nonhuman animals, and actively hide these practices…

They continue to block alternate forms of energy to keep us dependent on oil…

They have purposely covered up oil spills, accidents, faulty bookkeeping, and inactive ingredients in pursuit of profit…”

2) Corporations are attacking you. Since the 1980s, corporations have campaigned to label activists as “eco-terrorists.” They have pushed for outrageous prison sentences of activists like Tim DeChristopher. They have lobbied for federal legislation like the Animal Enterprise Terrorism Act and state legislation to label civil disobedience as “eco-terrorism.” They are doing everything in their power to marginalize and disrupt the environmental and animal rights movements. (In other words, as this clever Greenpeace video depicts, they’re afraid of you.) Rather than protesting bill by bill, arrest by arrest, this is an opportunity to challenge the true problem: unchecked corporate power.

3) You have experiences to share about tactics. Occupy Wall Street has locked arms to blockade the banks, and marched to the mansions of millionaires. Sound familiar? More than 800 1,200 environmentalists were arrested in a massive civil disobedience against the XL Pipeline. And the SHAC campaign brought a multinational corporation near bankruptcy through a diversity of tactics including home demonstrations. This obviously isn’t to say that environmentalists and animal rights activists created tactics like civil disobedience or home demonstrations, but they have, more than any other contemporary social movement, put them to unique and effective use targeting corporations. There are lessons to be shared– good, bad, and ugly– that will benefit everyone.

4) You have experiences to share about dealing with corporate and government repression. Occupy Wall Street has already seen some of the overt tactics used to target social movements, such as the police beating and pepper-spraying activists. As this movement grows, however, so will the proportionate backlash. You have experiences with informants, infiltrators, and corporate espionage. You have resisted grand jury witch hunts and fought back against restraining orders and injunctions. You have defeated draconian state legislation and organized effective prisoner support campaigns. To be clear, ya’ll aren’t alone! Other social movements have dealt with, are dealing with, this as well. But the backlash against the animal rights and environmental movements, the “Green Scare,” is a case study in all the post 9/11 tools available to corporations and those who represent them. I’ve sounded like a broken record on this website, but I’ll say it again. There’s nothing inevitable about any of this. By coming together and sharing experiences, we can coordinate and fight back.

5) This is bigger than all of us. By “this” I don’t mean Occupy Wall Street (although that’s part of it). I mean the task at hand. We all, out of necessity, focus on the issues that are most dear to us. We have limited time, limited money, limited resources. That’s why, for instance, I have carved out the field of work that I have. But listen: there are times for carving out our niches, and times for doing the hard work, the messy and uncomfortable and frustrating work, of trying to connect all of the pieces. Animal rights activists and environmentalists are often pegged by the broader, capital-L “Left” as “single issue,” but I have never found that to be true. This is an opportunity for all of us to share, as the Zapatista saying goes, “One no, many yeses.”

Slavoj Zizek captured this sentiment beautifully in an address to Occupy Wall Street:

In an old joke from the defunct German Democratic Republic, a German worker gets a job in Siberia; aware of how all mail will be read by censors, he tells his friends: “Let’s establish a code: if a letter you will get from me is written in ordinary blue ink, it is true; if it is written in red ink, it is false.” After a month, his friends get the first letter written in blue ink: “Everything is wonderful here: stores are full, food is abundant, apartments are large and properly heated, movie theatres show films from the West, there are many beautiful girls ready for an affair—the only thing unavailable is red ink.” And is this not our situation till now? We have all the freedoms one wants—the only thing missing is the red ink: we feel free because we lack the very language to articulate our unfreedom. What this lack of red ink means is that, today, all the main terms we use to designate the present conflict—’war on terror,’ “democracy and freedom,’ ‘human rights,’ etc—are FALSE terms, mystifying our perception of the situation instead of allowing us to think it.

You, here, you are giving to all of us red ink.

Want to take action? Start at the Occupy Wall Street main website. What are you planning in your city?

  • Anonymous

    Phenomenally inspiring, Will. Well done.

  • http://www.greenisthenewred.com Will Potter

    Thank you, Dan

  • Pingback: Will Potter and Mark Bittman on Occupy Wall Street

  • Gerardo

    There is so much opportunuity for AR folks joining Occupy! What about organizing togeter a ” Occupy your plate/kitchen event and talk abotu corporate greed and how it’s has fucked up the whole planet?

  • bobby

    Actually,  i would say it is these occupiers who should be vegan and animal rights activists if they make the full connection on how all will suffer until we stop killing all animals 

  • http://twitter.com/veganbonnie Bonnie S., Toronto

    I don’t agree. How many people at the Occupy events actually give a shit about animals? I haven’t heard word one about this. I saw pro-hunting Michael Moore on TV at the Wall Street occupation. How many Occupiers even know anything about factory farming, the fur trade, the seal hunt, puppy mills, etc. I wish there were a connection between Occupy and A/R, but I haven’t seen anything to indicate that there is.

  • http://www.greenisthenewred.com Will Potter

    Let me ask you one question: Do you think you have more in common with the people in the streets, or the corporations?

  • http://www.greenisthenewred.com Will Potter

    I don’t think that type of thinking, “Change is great — now you change first,” has ever gotten much accomplished. 

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_RL2RQH4UG2YLLASBVREQP5NT6M D'Sorceress

    There are no ‘single issue’ players in this or any other debate. One little ‘single issue’ that is often ignored in favor of hyperbole is this: No matter our differences in philosophy, if you want to have time and opportunity to espouse your positions, you are going to have to *eat.* And since precious few have the knowledge or resources to produce all of their own food, it is perilous to keep hacking away mindlessly at the existing structures in place that perform those jobs for those who cannot. The existing system is imperfect, as most are, and could use adjusting, as most can; but like it or not it came into being for one purpose: to provide the most food to the most people at an affordable price. Even at its limits, due to vagaries of weather and distribution obstacles, far too many people go to bed hungry or even die of lack of available, affordable food. Too many wanting to topple the infrastructure to show their power have any idea of the suffering that would result, globally, if they were to get their fondest wish. Destroying something because you can or because you hate it is not wisdom, not if that something is providing a necessary function. You are going to have to have something *tangible* to replace it first, and something that will work in the real world, not just on paper or in your fancies, or you risk causing greater suffering, FAR greater, than the suffering yo seek to address. Caution is not always an evil world. Be careful what you wish for.

  • Mableo8251

    very well put…this is what I have been trying to tell all my animal friends on FB which is most of my friends with no response…maybe me posting this will wake them up…

  • http://www.greenisthenewred.com Will Potter

    Glad to hear that. I hope it helps.

  • animal earth human liberation

    We are working on educating people at Occupy LA to understand why nonhuman animals and environment have to be part of this movement if it is to succeed. Feel free to use this outline:
    https://docs.google.com/document/d/1a7NPa2QrItWZclE5sfurz1PeI-f9BpV1zaeTdMsbkbA/edit?hl=en_US

  • Gerardo

    You shoudl go there and be visible not wait for the other do become this and that. That is if you are a real Activist!

  • Gerardo

    Will JUST told you five reasons and LOOK : They have profited off of the torture, confinement, and cruel treatment of countless nonhuman animals, and actively hide these practices… what else you want he? Gee,some people calling themselve AR activist really make me ashamed to say I am an AR activist…they remind me puritanists preaching.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_VF2UUBU2BOUHXNVJIAETYBBBCQ Joe

    Hey Will

    You are without a doubt one nut case. You are dangerous and are going to get people jailed and hurt and probably killed.  You people who are calling yourself the 99.0% are spoiled brats, You have no guarantee the world will give you something you have not earned. Get a job any job we all have to start at the bottom and work our way up based on performance, and dedication and our integrity.  Something you may have missed out on somewhere.  Americans
    are industrialist and hard working. I have never seen a marketable product come out of a bunch of bums sitting on their arse, complaining about life isn’t fair… Let tell something bud Life is not fair so get over it and get on with your life.  You may have a good career in front of you in a advertising company, you seem to have at least one talent.    

  • http://www.greenisthenewred.com Will Potter

    Joe the Troll is back!

  • Guest

    Orange County, CA readers, please encourage Occupy Orange County to “Go Vegan.”
    http://www.occupy-oc.org/needs/
    Thanks.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_VF2UUBU2BOUHXNVJIAETYBBBCQ Joe

    Well Will did you miss me… LOL

  • Guest

    Thanks so much for the encouragement to check out the Occupy movement!  I did and it was a fantastic experience.  People were courteous, respectful, informed and motivated.  I learned more than what I knew prior to this event, and everyone seemed excited to be able to bring up and talk about topics that seldom arise in everyday conversations.

  • Pingback: Occupy4Life: #revolution in the name of all species | The Fair Share of the Common Heritage

  • Jasper Wilcox

    In Portland the Occupy site is very passive. They are not all seasoned activists. It’s almost refreshing. I talk to them about being prepared for when the police come in and start busting heads and they don’t want any part from it.

    It’s important to ask yourself in what capacity you want to participate.

    Here’s what I’ve experienced: One night the Portland camp feared a raid from the police for “drug use.” I wanted to devise a plan – a defense. I got shot down by everybody. They all said the same thing: “Go limp – the NLG recommends you go limp and do not resist.”

    First it pissed me off – I thought: “whatever hippie, you’ll change your mind when they beat your ass.”

    Then I thought about it – decisions are made through the General Assembly.

    It’s impossible to devise a battle plan and then put it to the General Assembly without the pigs knowing it. Secrecy is impossible.

    To go outside the G.A. and try to plan a defensive strategy alone would not only undermine the G.A. but would be co-optive also.

    What I was doing was talking to individuals about how WE should defend ourselves if (when, inevitably) the cops come.

    If I were king of the world we’d have a plan to keep the Occupy site – but I’m not.

    I think that AR/Environmental activists have a place at the Occupations. In Portland (at least) they are not focusing on these issues at all. I think lock-downs are a good defensive tactic in Portland – because we’re right across the street from the police station.

    If arrests were going to be made I think people should block the entrances to the police station not lock arms around the park.

    I think people with communication devises should be planted outside of the occupy site to watch if cops are mobilizing.

    These things are not happening.

    Not only that, but a person trying to say this stuff gets flamed for being an Agent Provacateur (haven’t we all heard that one before…)

    I dunno – just some thoughts. It would suck if a group of people with different motivations decided to radicalize the event. It would be undemocratic.

    If these hippie kids and moderates want to democratically decide to get beat up by the police and lose their parks – well… that’s democracy.

    Those busted heads will inevitably swell our ranks at some later time.

    It would not be wrong to try to push more radical ideas through at the General Assembly, but – I dunno. It just doesn’t seem very pure. To get in there with information on veganism and the AR/Environmental movements however would be awesome – even in Portland there’s not enough of that happening. I see almost NO AR influence at the Occupy site aside from like a Wobbly table with the SHAC Model pamphlet on it.

    This information alone would be enough to put the idea into peoples’ heads – and that might be enough to get the crowd to wisen up a little bit. I’m of the opinion that police won’t get an order to make mass arrests (not in PDX at least) but to disperse the crowd. That means tear-gas and sticks.

    I could be wrong, but… It would surprise me because it’s never happened before :o P

  • Jasper Wilcox

    To make that long story very short – there is no discussion about a defensive plan at Occupy PDX and anybody who starts that discussion gets shot down for being an Agent Provocateur. There is very little discussion about the environment or animal rights. These things should be discussed, but we (maybe not me,I can’t talk for any ‘movement’) should try not to co-opt the event or undermine the G.A. IMHO

  • Pingback: The Vegan Police

  • Pingback: Occupy4Life: #revolution in the name of all species « The Spiral Ladder

  • Rosa

    At the Social Forum in Detroit 2011, the environmentalists and animal rights people seemed to be missing but of course, I do not know that for sure since I did not make it to the Anarchist space which was not right at the site at the convention center.

  • Brigitta

    Will and Jasper, thank you for posting what you have. 

    I admit to having been idle regarding Occupy because after trying to join forces in the past for this and that (AR and other related matters), I have encountered two sorts of folks:

    A, the type Jasper describes (Iowa City, Iowa, is chock full of ‘em–and I see them at all “stages of development”: college age, when being part of “something” is new and exciting; yuppie/grad school age when they think they’ve learned a thing or two about the world so can contribute and really get something done; and aging hippie, wanting a spark in their life since resting on one’s laurels gets old after awhile . . . point being, they are all over the age spectrum and never seem to really change for the better)

    OR

    B, wannabe activists caught up in the “hero high” of doing what they’re doing, losing sight of the importance of the key stages of planning and follow-through. 

    Will’s message inspired me when he wrote of the occupy effort concentrated on blocking access to banks and encroaching on the 1%’s precious (no doubt Mc-) mansions; I feel strongly that it’s this sort of shutdown and intimidation that is key.

    But . . . is SO HARD to get the hippie-slacktavist/yacktavist types to join forces.  I’m not sure what the answer is, aside from cloning dyed-in-the-nonwool AR activists and creating an army.  My generally nonviolent mind has even wondered things like, “When a place is occupied, isn’t it by force (weaponry)?” 

    I appreciate the sentiment of OWS, but I do wonder about its long-term efficacy if hanging out in parks is the primary “action”.  Please clue me in; by no means do I consider myself seasoned or well informed about this matter–just was moved to express a few thoughts I’ve had building up inside . . .

  • rodent

    Humans are the top 1% (or less) on planet Earth with ALL the rights.    Everyone else — the other animals — are the bottom 99% who are denied ANY meaningful, positvie rights at all on plant Earth and are merely at the “mercy” of the human 1%.  Unlike the human Occupiers protesting the other human 1%, the animal 99% cannot defend themselves against the hyperspecialized, overpopulated, destructive, violent, troubled, self-centered, and rapacious human 1% of planet Earth.  The animal 99% are nothing but “property,” “renewable resources,” or “pests” to the human 1%.    For the animal 99%, co-existence with the human 1% on planet Earth is like being trapped in a cage with a psychopath.  Despite Copernicus, despite Darwin, the human 1% almost always act as if it’s the only species that counts or matters, and liberals, “progressives,” and even environmentalists are the worst extremists.   That’s my position.

  • jj

    veganbonnie, how will ‘they’ every know about these things if ‘we’ don’t tell them, get the to your closest occupy & be the voice of animals!!  I mean this most sincerely, I’m part of a tiny occupy in a small city in Australia, animals have a voice in the square, because I’m there, it’s a messy, frustrating & beautiful thing striving for a genuine democracy that will include human & non-human animals, and the earth, but I sure as hell want to be able to say to my grandchildren that I wasn’t on the sidelines, cheers jj

  • Wolf Wizard

    This is a grand revolution and way to tell
    the corporate dictatorship that we’re not gonna
    walk lock-step and conform to their status
    quo of greed and corruption!!!!

  • http://maggie-mae-adventures.blogspot.com GraceLorraine

    ;) Have you got 1% reading your blog?!

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Jan-Fredericks/769048830 Jan Fredericks

    Confining and abusing billions of animals and then allowing commercials to advertise their meat and products brainwashes society.  The CEO’s of these factories and government are in control of the animals’ suffering for $$$$.  Animals should be included in the movement – hopefully people will ‘get it’.  Matthew Scully, a former senior speechwriter for Pres. G W Bush, wrote ‘Dominion: The Power of Man, the Suffering of Animals, and the Call to Mercy’.   Churches should also be proclaiming the truth about the evil of factory farms and not support them.
    Jan
    God’s Creatures Ministry

  • Matt Leonard

    Great article Will. Radicals love to stake out ground and argue nuances about how we are different than other social movements, and set up dividing lines between even very close allies. Critiques are good and healthy – but having solidarity, building MASS movement, and being willing to compromise in order to actually move us in the right direction is the only way we create change. While I love the rhetoric of “No compromise” and its catchy and all, but its not very realistic. Such stances can do some powerful campaign work in a small niche in a fairly insular community – but it can’t transform the world.
    The #occupy movement in many cities are folks new to activism – who are discovering their voice, figuring out their political analysis, and jumping into new ideas of how to organize society, or even just make decisions in a small community. Let’s face it – many of us radials could be a different 1% – and it’s time we also join up with the 99% and  Experienced organizers, campaigners – or even just folks who have thought-out their politics would be smart to join in and help popularize our ideas in ways that resonate with the 99% and inspire them – rather than stand on the sidelines, critique, and or alienate people who are just getting involved.FYI – there were 1200 folks arrested in DC for the Tar Sands Action last month, not 800…  ;)

  • http://www.greenisthenewred.com Will Potter

    Well said, thanks Matt

  • Judella

    one can be pro hunting and be pro animal.  I don’t think Michael Moore would be a good example of this.  I think those in the Lierre Keith and Derrick Jensen camp could make a strong argument for hunting as being inclusive within the ecosystem, and would perhaps state to not do so is simply removing yourself from such an ecosystem, like most humanists do.

  • Pingback: 5 Reasons Why Environmentalists and Animal Activists Should Occupy Wall Street « Women Born Transsexual

  • Guest

    Hello, are you able to indicate or display number of comments by the post title?

  • Pingback: ‘Occupy’ for Public Lands & Wildlife - HUNTİNG ALL – HUNTİNG ALL

  • http://www.animalliberationaction.org/ Brandon Becker

    Lierre Keith and Derrick Jensen are speciesists and have no critique of domestication, the greatest force driving civilization. Indeed, they support enslaving animals for human consumption and are not anarchists or primitivists. I’ll take them seriously when they endorse animal liberation.

  • http://www.greenisthenewred.com Will Potter

    It’s a feature that got lost in the redesign, but I could look into that.

  • Guest

    :-)   Thanks, Will.

  • Pingback: Food Day and Occupy Wall Street | True Love Health

  • Anonymous

    What I’d like to know is when and where is there going to be an OCCUPY THE FUCKERS WHO ENACTED AETA march?

  • Jasper Wilcox

    I said over and over again at Occupy Portland: “The police won’t come here to make arrests, but to disperse the crowd. They will use tear-gas and sticks. You talk to them now and you’re all laughs and smiles, but don’t forget that same cop will not hesitate to beat your ass. He will beat women down with a stick. He won’t think twice about it.”

    Everybody either shut me down with a high-pitched Chakra tuning or called me an “Agent Provacateur.”

    What happened in Oakland? They dispersed the crowd with tear-gas and stick and arrested the ones that didn’t leave. And there’s an Iraq war vet in critical condition somewhere – how do you think a bunch of stoned hippies will fare?

  • Guest

    The “99%” out protesting on the streets have
    nothing but apathy for the animals.  I feel like a sole voice being all but shot down or politely ignored or being told to shut up in no uncertain terms.  There are 50 times more vegans attending a f*ing potluck in my city than speaking up and lending a voice.

  • Jasper Wilcox

    It’s too easy to poop on the Deep Green Resistance people. I don’t like to call myself Vegan, but I sure do try. I don’t ever eat animal flesh, that’s for sure. But who cares?

    That doesn’t make me cooler than everybody else.

    My best friends are not only not vegan they think my politics are stupid. Some of ‘em are Republicans. Whattaya do? I went to high school with those kids. My mom’s not Vegan. I’ve never locked myself to her refrigerator and demanded she stop.

    There are vegan activists, yeah – but there’s a lot of social justice stuff going on and most of the people fighting for it aren’t vegan.

    Bastards!

    Some of those non-vegan activists are down as fuck… I’d trust ‘em if it came down to it.

    Anti-war people aren’t counter-revolutionary because they go to Denny’s and eat a sausage. Who cares? Labor people aren’t counter-revolutionary because they eat steak.

    That’s where it gets wishy-washy and we start demanding shit from people. Keith goes on and on about how dumb veganism is and she sounds like a big fat Nazi, but I’ve met some vegan straight edge kids who are just as nazi about me smoking some weed. Everybody alienates somebody – especially when  you talk to people like they’re stupid. You could turn everybody off from everything by being an asshole – vegan, omnivore, whatever…

    I’d like to have some say about how huge corporations mistreat (murder, hurt) animals, but I don’t care what Lierre Keith does.

    Activism, especially anarchism, tends to attract people who are just negative and who are against everything. All morals and dry farts. I dont care who it is. Beautiful, trendy, vegan anarchists are almost ALL rude to me – without fail. It doesnt make me not want to be vegan. Who cares what other people do?

    Do your own thing.

    Lierre Keith is totally guilty of this! But so are a bunch of beautiful, trendy, vegan anarchists. It’s not about being on the post-modern cutting edge of trendy coolness – it’s about getting rid of exploitation (human animal or environment) and maybe drawing a little blood from capitalism (hopefully.)

  • http://disoccupy.wordpress.com/ Bob

    I’ll pay more attention to this movement when it gets beyond the leftist shit that its clinging to. I don’t have any more in common with these people then I do with the corporations they are protesting. I don’t see them examining anything in any way that isn’t superficial. Maybe I’m wrong but this movement doesn’t even have the clarity of being against capitalism or the corporations themselves. Their issues are with corruption, greed, and like matters, and they fail to take it further to understand the source of these issues. They can start to talk about environmental and animal liberation issues, but in the end, they’ll talk about it with the same superficiality as they do everything else, and we’ll hear the nonsense about “green” energy and having a more humane system. Fuck that.

    And lets not forget that this is already occupied land, how about talking about decolonizing this land.

  • Barb

    NYT is asking how they should cover OWS. Comment here – http://publiceditor.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/11/04/occupy-wall-street-how-should-it-be-covered-now/

    Would love to have you Will, post a comment on corporate influence over our constitutional rights, ie., AETA.  Please do help them ’connect all the dots’ as you say.

  • Barb

    This ought to give us all enough reason to get out and join OWS movement. http://www.negotiationisover.net/2011/11/03/breaking-activist-chris-lagergren-with-a-felony-today/

  • Pingback: Random Thoughts » Occupying and Jesus

  • Pingback: Pět důvodů, proč by environmentalisté a aktivisté za práva zvířat měli také Okupovat Wall Street | GreenAction

  • Pingback: Green is the New Red: Cutting through the Fog of Fear « Literary Animal

  • Pingback: FBI = American Gestapo » The Vegan Evolution

  • Pingback: FBI Says Activists Who Investigate Factory Farms Can Be Prosecuted As TERRORISTS!

  • Pingback: Two Wrongs Don’t Make A Right | www.CanineAdvice.Org

  • Pingback: FBI Says Activists Who Investigate Factory Farms Can Be Prosecuted as Terrorists

Previous post:

Next post: