Glenn Beck is Our Real-Life Lewis Prothero

by Will Potter on May 23, 2010

in Terrorism Scare Mongering

“It’s one of the most evil books ever,” said Glenn Beck, holding up a copy of The Coming Insurrection. (The video starts at 2:30). He then held up a copy of We Are an Image From the Future as he went on a nonsensical tirade against the threat of “communists” who want to destroy families.

For the most part, I think it’s a waste of time to get wrapped up in Glenn Beck’s nonsense. Being absurd and bombastic is this guy’s shtick. He has made millions doing it. When people start calling books “evil,” though, I think that’s reason to pay attention.

We should be concerned when people like Glenn Beck call books “evil” because people like Glenn Beck don’t read. For instance, the books he railed against were not written by communists, but by anarchists, a point which AK Press addressed in a very well-crafted response.

Or, perhaps Beck and his producers have read the books, know what they say, and they just don’t care. I really have no idea.

lewis prothero v for vendettaIt’s hard to tell if people like Beck are stupid, or evil, or both. And that’s why, when I watched the clip above, I felt like I was watching a skit.

Give Glenn Beck a British accent, and is he not the spitting image of Lewis Prothero in “V is for Vendetta,” the scare-mongering talking head keeping an Orwellian country in perpetual fear?

The over-the-top hysteria; the scare-mongering against immigrants, unions, and anyone who is an “other”; the warnings that American values and families are under attack… it just doesn’t seem real. It is too much. Too far. It doesn’t seem real because we’ve seen this before, in films and literature whenever an artist wants to create an exaggerated, larger-than-life symbol of freedom sacrificed in the name of fear.

More and more, it feels like we are living fiction.

  • Matthew

    I don't get it. Why is this too far, or just doesn't it seem real?

    The only reason it seems unreal or too far to me is that we (the radical left) are so impotent in america that this just seems silly to me/us. Books are all we have, but they never amount to shit. The possibility of any emancipatory politics realizing itself in america is so remote (so laughable) that is is astonishing that this guy gets worried about it. The books represent fantasy, are thus innocuous, and therefor aren't anything to give any real credence to. So when he does, it seems shocking.

    I wish we were somewhere where the threats/promises of these books, protests, unions, and ideas were something for people to worry about. These books/ideas/protests/unions/etc do (and should) challenge everything that this guy (and the people he represents) love and cherish. I think that's great. I love that he's scared. I just wish we had the power to make his fear legitimate.

  • http://www.greenisthenewred.com Will Potter

    My interest wasn't so much in the books, or whether they represent any kind of a threat. This type of talk from Beck and others is nothing new, and neither is the (lack of effective) response from the left.

    But doesn't it strike you as unreal that we can turn on TV and there, in real life, is the kind of dystopian authoritarian rhetoric that would be trite in most fiction?

    Maybe it's just me, but I think what makes this seem so unreal, and what prompted this post, is that when the exact same rhetoric appears in some fantasy world in a movie or book or whatever, there's not a single viewer or reader who would fail to recognize the absurdity and threat of it all. But how do we respond, in real life? The left ignores it, the right eats it up, and everyone else seems to thing it's normal.

  • hawkgirl

    It is so unreal, like a crude skit with Beck trying to assign oversimplified roles of cowboys in black hats and white hats. It's part of a grand illusion: just one of many spectacles that tries to distract us from the crumbling foundation of capitalism. Spectacle is political novocaine. It kills critical thought, smothers rebellion, and postpones social change. We each have the power for changing the cultural direction of our own community and making new traditions, when we trust ourselves to take action. We only need to begin or, if we've already begun, to persist. And others will eventually join in.

    Suppose no one ever started this blog to contribute to deconstructing the AETA and the Green Scare. Every voice counts.

Previous post:

Next post: